beatty wozniak

News & Insights

Serving Energy Industries Nationwide

Cos. Face Uncertainty Over Parallel Updates To LNG Rules

November 20, 2026 | Insights

Two Proposals, One Framework

Within two weeks of each other, the principal federal regulators of liquefied natural gas (LNG) facilities each moved to bring their rules in line with today’s industry. On October 15, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) proposed a blanket authorization program for LNG plants (Docket No. RM26-2-001). On October 28, the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) put forward a comprehensive revision of its LNG safety regulations at 49 C.F.R. Part 193 (Docket No. PHMSA-2019-0091). That revision would update the industry standard at the core of Part 193 and tailor requirements to each facility’s size and function.

Both rulemakings recognize how much the industry has changed. When PHMSA adopted Part 193 in 1980, the sector consisted mostly of small peak-shaving facilities and a handful of import terminals. There were no export terminals in the lower 48 and only one in the entire United States. When FERC last considered extending blanket authority to LNG plants, in 2006, the first cargo shipped from Sabine Pass was still a decade away. Today the United States is the world’s largest LNG exporter.

FERC is streamlining how changes to LNG facilities are authorized, while PHMSA is updating the safety standard they must meet. Both agencies acknowledge the need to coordinate, but neither explains how the two sets of rules will fit together. Developers of new export projects and operators planning expansions will need that answer before either rulemaking concludes.

Two Modernization Efforts

PHMSA’s proposal is the most significant change to LNG safety regulation since Part 193 was adopted. To apply a 1980-era framework to modern LNG facilities, PHMSA has had to rely on guidance in the form of frequently asked questions (FAQs), which are not legally binding. The rulemaking also responds to mandates in the PIPES Acts of 2016 and 2020, and PHMSA estimates annualized cost savings of nearly $100 million.

PHMSA would amend Part 193 to incorporate by reference the 2026 edition of the National Fire Protection Association’s Standard 59A (NFPA 59A). It would also codify select FAQ provisions, including its design spill criteria and siting package requirements. Codifying them would give operators the regulatory certainty that guidance cannot provide.

FERC’s proposal marks a comparable shift in its own rules. The Commission declined to extend blanket authority to LNG plants in 1982 and again in 2006. Citing its experience with more than 100 LNG applications since then, it now proposes a tiered approach modeled on its well-established interstate natural gas pipeline blanket certificate program.

The program would have three tiers. Under the automatic tier, in-footprint replacements, upgrades, and additions that do not increase capacity could proceed without advance notice to FERC. Under two prior notice tiers, capacity increases within the footprint could proceed 60 days after notice. New trains, tanks, and berths occupying up to 25 additional acres could proceed after 90 days. Both would be subject to protest. The program would replace a change-reporting practice that industry commenters described as lacking clarity with defined paths and timelines.

A Modern Standard Meets Legacy Conditions

Neither proposal can be read in isolation, because each changes how the other would work in practice. The clearest example is a question that predates both: whether FERC should continue imposing its own safety conditions once Part 193 is current. The Natural Gas Act gives FERC broad authority to condition its authorizations, including on safety grounds. By its own count, FERC has issued more than 4,500 requirements in LNG proceedings. Setting federal safety standards for LNG facilities, however, is PHMSA’s role under the Pipeline Safety Act.

In its proposal, PHMSA acknowledges that its own delay in updating Part 193 “encouraged FERC to exercise its statutory authority to impose more legally binding, safety-related conditions.” The proposed rule addresses many of those gaps and, with them, much of the rationale for FERC’s conditions. FERC’s blanket program, however, would keep those conditions in force, even for equipment installed after PHMSA’s update.

Once PHMSA’s final rule takes effect, new or replaced equipment at an existing terminal must meet the amended design requirements. For prior notice activities, FERC’s proposal also requires that equipment to meet the codes in the terminal’s original order, or “approved equivalents.” FERC does not define or explain “approved equivalents,” so it is unclear whether compliance with the updated Part 193 would satisfy the requirement.

FERC’s proposal acknowledges that PHMSA has exclusive authority to set federal safety standards for LNG facilities. Yet the proposal signals that FERC intends to remain the lead agency on LNG safety. Its blanket program would leave existing order conditions in place and add FERC safety criteria of its own. The overlap with PHMSA’s rule is extensive. PHMSA’s description of FERC’s typical conditions, which cover process hazard analyses, management of change, pre-startup safety reviews, mechanical integrity, hot work, and contractor oversight, tracks almost element for element the process safety program PHMSA proposes for FERC-regulated facilities.

If that approach carries into the final rule, it would codify a long-standing problem: an overlapping safety regime in which operators serve two masters, each with its own statute, enforcement process, inspectors, and standards. PHMSA’s update would fill many of the gaps FERC’s conditions were meant to address. With those gaps closed, PHMSA could serve as the primary regulator of LNG safety. If FERC writes its own safety conditions into regulation in the same areas PHMSA is amending in Part 193, both proposals will miss an opportunity to deliver regulatory certainty and streamlined operations.

FERC’s Fast Lane Runs Through PHMSA

Operators could not use either prior notice tier without first obtaining a PHMSA determination. For the first time, a FERC regulation would make such a determination a prerequisite to filing. FERC’s proposed rule would require a PHMSA Letter of Determination (LOD) confirming that the activity complies with federal siting rules or that those standards do not apply.

FERC’s 60- and 90-day notice periods are designed to keep these applications moving. PHMSA’s rulemaking, however, does not set a corresponding deadline for issuing an LOD, and FERC’s notice period would not begin until PHMSA acts. Unless the two rulemakings are brought into alignment, the time savings the blanket program promises may not be achieved, particularly while PHMSA is implementing its own new rules.

Nor does the agencies’ 2018 memorandum of understanding (MOU) fill that gap. It calls for PHMSA to issue an LOD no later than 30 days before the estimated issuance date of FERC’s final environmental impact statement or environmental assessment. Under the prior notice tiers, the operator would need the LOD before submitting its request.

Given the extent of the proposed changes in both agencies’ regulations, the MOU will likely need revision. If PHMSA’s final rule does not set a deadline for LODs supporting prior notice filings, the revised MOU could establish one.

A Five-Year Gap Between Design and Siting Implementation

PHMSA’s proposed implementation plan could create problems because its rule would take effect in two stages. The amended design, construction, and operating requirements, based on NFPA 59A-2026, would apply on the final rule’s effective date. The siting provisions, which govern hazard modeling and exclusion zones, would not apply until five years after the final rule is published. This staggered implementation would most directly affect new terminals seeking FERC approval because each LOD reflects how PHMSA applies the siting provisions.

During those five years, a developer would have the option of following either the existing siting requirements, which are based on NFPA 59A-2001, or the amended ones. It could not combine the two. That choice would determine the hazard modeling assumptions in the operator’s siting analysis, which PHMSA would rely on in issuing its LOD. A new terminal that chooses the NFPA 59A-2001 siting requirements would still have to meet the NFPA 59A-2026 design requirements, which apply on the effective date. Existing facilities would keep their original siting basis, adopting NFPA 59A-2026 only for new or replaced equipment and any later siting review.

Allowing two sets of siting requirements in parallel also complicates PHMSA’s plan for its LNG FAQs, which it proposes to rescind once a final rule is adopted. Some would be codified in the amended rules, and others would be set aside as superseded or no longer applicable. That approach fits facilities sited under the amended requirements. It does not fit those sited under the existing requirements during the transition, including existing terminals that make changes requiring new siting review.

The current siting FAQs interpret the existing Part 193 requirements. PHMSA does not say whether it would rescind the FAQs when the final rule takes effect or wait five years until the amended siting requirements apply. If it rescinds them when the rule takes effect, facilities sited under NFPA 59A-2001 during the transition would lose guidance PHMSA has applied for more than a decade, without a replacement.

PHMSA’s phased implementation would also carry into FERC’s process. FERC’s proposed rule refers only to “federal siting requirements,” so during the transition FERC could receive LODs resting on NFPA 59A-2001 for some projects and NFPA 59A-2026 for others. Blanket activities at existing terminals would modify facilities built to more than one NFPA standard. And if the siting FAQs are rescinded early, PHMSA’s reviews under NFPA 59A-2001 could become less predictable, delaying the prior notice filings that depend on them.

Older Terminals Fall Outside FERC’s Baseline

FERC’s reliance on PHMSA’s siting work is not limited to the prior notice tiers. Under proposed 18 C.F.R. § 153.108(c)(3)(iii), the automatic tier would allow operators to proceed without notifying FERC in advance. That option would be limited to activities that would not “result in significant modification to LNG facilities beyond what was previously evaluated by [PHMSA] and considered by the Commission.” PHMSA, however, began conducting those siting reviews only in 2018.

Facilities authorized before 2018, therefore, do not have a PHMSA evaluation. As proposed, FERC’s rules would disqualify all such facilities from utilizing the automatic blanket certificate tier. Given that most of the large-scale export terminals operating today were authorized before 2018, the exclusion would reach the core of the industry.

Whether FERC intends that result is unclear. If it does, the automatic tier would largely benefit terminals authorized after 2018, a significant limit on a program designed to streamline changes at existing LNG plants.

Modernizing the Relationship

FERC’s and PHMSA’s proposals represent significant advances in modernizing LNG regulation. FERC would establish a more predictable authorization process for modifications to existing facilities, while PHMSA would update Part 193 to reflect current technology, industry standards, and operating practices. Both proposals address longstanding regulatory concerns and offer meaningful benefits to LNG developers and operators.

Considered together, however, the proposals reveal shortcomings that neither agency fully addresses. The continued application of FERC’s safety conditions alongside PHMSA’s updated standards, the absence of a defined timeline for PHMSA determinations supporting blanket authorizations, and the complications created by PHMSA’s phased implementation could undermine the certainty and efficiency both agencies seek to provide. The concurrent rulemakings give FERC and PHMSA an opportunity to address these issues before their respective rules are finalized. Meaningful coordination would allow the agencies to preserve the benefits of each proposal while establishing a more consistent and predictable regulatory framework for LNG facilities.

FERC comments are due December 21, 2026, in Docket No. RM26-2-001. PHMSA comments are due January 4, 2027, in Docket No. PHMSA-2019-0091.

Also featured in Law360 here.